Senate Democrats reject quick exit from Schumer vs. Van Hollen fight

Posted

Senate Democrats are preparing for their all-consuming fight over who will lead them next year to drag on for weeks.

The contentious battle between Sens. Chuck Schumer of New York and Chris Van Hollen of Maryland has already become, in the minds of some Democrats, a massive distraction from the work of preparing for a new majority and looming battles with President Donald Trump.

But interviews with about a dozen Democratic senators and senior aides Monday revealed little appetite to end the drama this week by moving up the closed-door election currently scheduled for Dec. 1.

“I would oppose expediting before we’ve had a full process,” said Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.), who hasn’t backed a candidate.

Sen. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.), who is also publicly uncommitted, said, “I don’t think that’s going to happen.”

Moving up the vote would have been viewed as benefiting Schumer, the longtime top Democrat who said last week he had secured the votes for a second stint as majority leader. But Schumer has not called for changing the schedule, and Van Hollen is publicly opposed to any such move.

Given that, and the uproar among many Democratic voters unhappy with Schumer’s recent leadership, senators appear willing to tough it out for two more weeks. They include Schumer allies, Van Hollen diehards and the dozens of publicly undecided Senate Democrats — even as some privately express a desire to avoid being constantly pressed for public commitments in the race, and many more wish to refocus on their governing agenda.

Tuesday’s caucus lunch is the first time Senate Democrats will gather in person since Van Hollen announced his leadership bid Thursday night. A senator could use the opportunity to call for a vote to waive caucus rules and hold the election later this week. Instead, some Democrats said Tuesday they were simply hoping for a robust discussion.

“It’s a family conversation that we’re going to have amongst ourselves,” said Sen. Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-Del.).

Van Hollen has been waging an unusually public campaign for leader that began with a cable-TV interview Thursday and has since expanded to include a “Chris for Leader” website and multiple Sunday talk show interviews. In an interview with POLITICO Sunday, he not only called for new leadership but also openly criticized Schumer’s record — pointing out, for instance, his opposition to the 2015 Iran nuclear deal that Trump later tore up.

“I’m really worried that we might blow what could be a huge opportunity to deliver,” Van Hollen said Monday, adding that he believes he has “momentum” in his supporter count.

Schumer, meanwhile, has focused almost solely on talking privately with colleagues since late last week — sticking to the traditional approach to a race that will be decided on a secret ballot of the 55 or 56 Democratic senators set to be sworn in early next year. He’s still viewed as the favorite due to the relationships he has built, funds he has raised and victories the party notched in this month’s midterms.

“I have a long history with Chuck,” said Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii), who became the latest senator to publicly back Schumer Monday.

But scores of Senate Democrats are staying quiet. Coming out in support of Schumer would only put a target on their backs with some Democratic activists, who are ramping up an external pressure campaign on behalf of Van Hollen and remain furious over Schumer’s decision early in Trump’s second term to advance a GOP funding bill as well as his reluctance to cut off U.S. aid to Israel, among other issues.

While Schumer says he’s gathered the minimum 28 or 29 votes to win, only about 15 have publicly backed that support. Several others, granted anonymity to describe their intentions without courting public backlash, privately say they will support him. Van Hollen, meanwhile, has put his supporter count around 15, though his public endorsements so far remain in the single digits.

Otherwise, the public whip count has largely stagnated after an initial round of endorsements after Van Hollen jumped in last week — even as some senators conspicuously praise the incumbent leader.

Hickenlooper, for instance, made a coin-toss motion when asked who he was supporting. But he appeared to question why some Democrats were trying to ditch Schumer after they just outperformed even the rosiest election projections.

“Leave it to the Democrats that we flip nine seats, and the person who actually helps put it all together and do all that and all of a sudden, there's a revolt,” he said.

Sen. Tim Kaine (D-Va.) also said he was undecided before listing Schumer’s assets: “Chuck delivered an amazing win. Chuck knows Trump, and that'll be really really important going forward.”

“No one, who is not on the ballot, worked harder for this victory than Chuck Schumer,” Kaine said before adding a third consideration: “Voters are demanding change.”

Several other veteran senators declined to state their voting intentions Monday. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), who is expected to become Banking chair and is looking to move up the leadership ladder, did not respond to questions from reporters in the halls. Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.), another member of leadership and a potential 2028 contender, used the same terms as Blunt Rochester, calling the matter a “family conversation.”

Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.), who stopped just short of calling on Schumer to resign last year, dodged questions from reporters, while Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), who has been critical of Schumer and the DSCC’s approach to primaries, also said Monday he is in listening mode.

“I’m going to hear them both out, and I want to hear from the freshman class as well,” he said.

Katherine Tully-McManus and Calen Razor contributed to this report. 

Congress, DC, Senate Democrats, Chuck Schumer, Chris Van Hollen, 2026 Elections, John Hickenlooper, Jon Ossoff, Lisa Rochester, Tim Kaine